Welcome to McGarrets
McGarrets, nestled on Elmwood Ave in Buffalo, NY, is a cherished dive bar steeped in history, previously known as establishments like Heenans and No Names. It has remained a local staple, celebrated for its welcoming atmosphere and rich selection of craft beers, including options from Flying Bison and Founders. Customers rave about the friendly staff, pool tables, and live music, making it a cozy oasis away from the bustling nightlife. With a cash-only policy, it's a reminder of the simplicity that defines this beloved bar, allowing patrons to unwind while enjoying perfectly chilled brews in a relaxed setting.
-
946 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222, United States Hotline: +1 716-883-4913
Welcome to McGarrets, an iconic establishment nestled in the heart of Buffalo, New York, at 946 Elmwood Ave. This beloved bar has undergone many transformations over the years, previously known as No Names, Heenans, and '946', yet its charm and vibrant atmosphere remain ever-present. It stands as a proud testament to the local community, offering a welcoming escape from the busyness of life.
McGarrets is renowned for its impressive selection of beers, boasting a well-curated list that features local favorites like Founders All Day IPA and Flying Bison Rusty Chain, as well as classics such as Sierra Nevada Pale Ale and New Belgium Fat Tire Amber Ale. With something for every palate, beer enthusiasts have much to explore here. The cozy interior invites patrons to unwind, whether they’re catching up with friends, enjoying a live band, or challenging each other to a game of pool.
- Atmosphere: The classic dive bar appeal of McGarrets is both nostalgic and refreshing. It's a place where you can comfortably chat without feeling overwhelmed by the crowd.
- Craft Beers: The bar takes pride in its local craft beer selection. From Flying Bison Blizzard Bock to Great Lakes Christmas Ale, there’s always something to savor.
- Customer Experience: Personal touches matter here. Patrons like Nichole L. appreciate the nostalgia, while others benefit from the commendable service and cash-only policy, which ensures a laid-back, straightforward experience.
- Entertainment: With live music and plenty of seating, including an inviting patio, McGarrets offers a variety of happenings to enjoy.
The reviews speak volumes about the communal spirit that McGarrets embodies. Patrons describe it as a hidden gem with a friendly vibe—perfect for those seeking a comfortable environment away from more crowded bars in the area. The reasonable prices and diverse beer selection consistently earn this bar high praises from locals and visitors alike.
As a food reviewer, it’s clear that McGarrets has carved out a unique place in Buffalo's bar scene. It delivers not just drinks but experiences rich with history and community spirit. So whether you’re a long-time resident or a curious traveler, McGarrets invites you to sit back, sip a cold beer, and enjoy a beloved Buffalo tradition.
Call me biased, but my father was a DJ for this place YEARS ago, in the 80s when it was known as No Names. It's just nice that the bar's still open, it makes me happy to see that. Thanks for taking care of the ol' joint, sincerely
Tried and true and cash only. This place has been a buffalo staple since time immemorial. Previously 'Heenans' '946' and 'no-names'. This place is a great bar in a great space and always has something going on. Great tap and bottle selection.
Great, underrated bar. Lots of great craft beer and a friemdly, low-key environment for those of us who can't cope with the Allen or Chippewa crowds. Keep in mind they only accept cash.
Great selection for a smaller place, I’ve seen a lot of good bands here too. Two pool tables make it worth the trip and it’s two doors down from Jim’s if you’re down for some late night garbage fare.
Great service and the drinks are cold! Friendly staff and a warm welcome! Money well spent!
The classic dive bar, and I mean that in the most complimentary way possible. Good beer selection, friendly bartenders. Great spot to relax, play darts, hang out on the patio. Can get a little loud when there's a band, but you can always escape to the other room or the patio.
Like this place because it's never too crowded or crazy. Prices are very reasonable and there's a pretty good beer selection. Good place to hang out with a few friends.
McGarrets was a great stop for a cold beer on a hot day. Cash-only, so plan accordingly, but good selection of local beers, very reasonable prices, and a great location in Elmwood. Friendly, helpful staff, plenty of seating, and a good vibe.